Pies! Pies! Pies!

Few things are more satisfying than a homemade pie, and we put a lot of love into every one we bake. We carry our classic fruit pies in store (while supplies last) and have a variety of specialty flavors, like chocolate cream, key lime, and more, available for pre-order!

Whether you're looking for a classic fruit pie or a specialty flavor, we recommend pre-ordering online to ensure you get the flavor you want!

All fruit pie flavors are available as gluten-free and vegan. Gluten-free and vegan pies are for pre-order only.

Specialty Pie Flavors:

Coconut Cream*
Chocolate Cream*
Key Lime
Peanut Butter

Seasonal Pie Flavors:

Pecan*
Pumpkin*
Strawberry Rhubarb*

*Available in gluten-free

Nantucket Baking Company Pies

Pies