Simply the best

Nantucket Baking Company's menu features a variety of cakes in different flavors and sizes—from rich, chocolate-forward tortes to refreshing, fresh-fruit-filled cakes. For more information on our cake sizes and placing an order, please continue to the information below.

Classic Cake Orders

We need a minimum of 72 hours' notice for classic cakes with a simple buttercream design. Classic cakes can include an inscription, fresh fruit garnish, nuts, sprinkles, chocolate curls, caramel or chocolate drips, and a simple border (top and bottom) at no additional cost. More intricate cake designs are considered custom or specialty—see below for more information.

To order from our menu, please visit our online shop to explore our pre-built options or create your own flavor combination using the "Build Your Own" listing.

Custom Cake Orders

We offer a wide range of customization options that make your cake truly one-of-a-kind! Custom cakes include themed and detailed designs or specialty requests that require extra attention.

All custom cake orders are subject to availability and require a minimum of 2 weeks' notice—availability is not guaranteed.

To inquire about a custom cake, please visit our custom order page and complete the form to submit your request.

Custom Cake Request Page

Wedding Cake Orders

To inquire about cutting or wedding cakes, please visit our Weddings & Events page and complete the form to submit your request.