Home Shop Pies Pies View all products Apple Bourbon Cranberry Pecan Pie Apple Bourbon Cranberry Pecan Pie $40.00 each No pickup date selected. Cream Pies Cream Pies $23.00 each No pickup date selected. Fruit Pie Fruit Pie $23.00 each No pickup date selected. Fruit Pie - GF Fruit Pie - GF $28.00 each Our classic fruit pie with our signature dutch crumble topping, all made without... No pickup date selected. Fruit Pie - Vegan Fruit Pie - Vegan $28.00 each our classic fruit pie made with all vegan ingredients. No pickup date selected. Key Lime Pie Key Lime Pie $23.00 each Graham cracker crust, key lime curd and fresh cream No pickup date selected. Lemon Meringue Pie Lemon Meringue Pie $23.00 each Our 9 inch buttery and flaky pie crust is filled with fresh lemon curd and merin... No pickup date selected. Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Pie $50.00 each No pickup date selected. Pecan Pie Pecan Pie $23.00 each No pickup date selected. Pumpkin Pie Pumpkin Pie $23.00 each A holiday classic. a beautiful velvety pumpkin custard in our butter shell.... No pickup date selected. Triple Decker Pie Triple Decker Pie $60.00 each A Nantucket Masterpiece! One layer NY cheesecake, one layer pumpkin pie, one lay... No pickup date selected. Can't find what you're looking for? Send us a message and let us know what you need. Leave this field blank Name Phone Email Message Send Message